X
Cart
100% Satisfaction Guaranteed

start your year off right - order a subscription box in jan and receive 2 free lbs of ground wagyu with your first subscription order

Stay Classy Meats Product Reviews

Read what our customers have to say about our product and service. We aim to provide a great product with great service.
Based on 727 reviews
87%
(629)
6%
(46)
2%
(17)
2%
(15)
3%
(20)
Yes please!

So full disclosure, I listen to Jason Ellis and that how I found Stay Classy Meats, for what it’s worth you’ve got a customer for life! I was skeptical about there being a distinct difference in flavor, and overall quality of the meat. I WILL BE TALKING ABOUT THIS ON MY PODCAST!!! 🖤🖤🖤

Love!

Such a treat to get this box. Could do without the jerky but otherwise excellent choices. The steaks are sooo good!

Better than Omaha’s

Portions are better and everything tasted great. Would definitely recommend to a friend.

Old Meat?

Hi,

A couple of comments here. First, I’ve noticed some of the meat packaged has a date of August. This is especially the case with ground beef. Seems like we’re getting pretty old meat, no? Is there an option to get more fresh meat? Also, will pork chops be coming each box? I’ve had 3 deliveries now and they all seem pretty identical. Be nice to switch it up.

Have not had a chance to try them yet however the shipping was fast and look forward to that time !

Very impressed

Great products, easy all around plus shows up next day at your door. Will be a return customer.

I was impressed with how quickly my order was shipped and the quality of the meat!

Boneless Prime Rib

Absolutely love this. Also great leftovers.

Cutting Board Excellence

Beautiful product!!!

Small amount

Purchased box for Christmas was disappointed in the thickness of steaks, taste of pork chops, and overall amount of meat for $125

Hi Charles,
Thank you for reviewing. We strive to provide good descriptions on all the products we offer. Reading your review made us take a better look at our product description, which we will add more details. The 2 x 8oz Beef Ribeye searing steaks are probably the product you mentioned about being disappointed about the thickness. While a lot of people like these, if you were expecting a 16oz 1.5'-2' steak, I could see the misaligned expectation. Regarding the Pork, we have never heard anything bad about the Pork. We use a heritage breed cross of Tamworth and Berkshire. I will have our production manager look into this claim because taste and quality of the Pork is highly important to us.
All feedback is good feedback. We would like to earn an elevated rating and we will be reaching out to you via email to find a solution.
Thank you for taking the time to write to us!

Core II Box - 12 lbs

Perfect

The cutting board was the perfect addition. Another excellent product from Stay Classy.

This was a gift

Feed back from the recipients was Thank You and it was great!

Very Disappointed

On christmas eve when we went to make our goose, It was rotten.

Hi Eric.
This is very surprising to hear since all the Goose are blast frozen immediately after processing, and processing happened in early December. I will follow up with you in an email to learn more of what happened and to resolve this issue.
Thank you!

Christmas Goose

Anorexic goose was a big disappointment. Barely weighing 7 pounds, it was not enough for for my 6 guests. Advertised a 8 to 10 pounds.
Not worth $98

Hi Elke,
I am very sorry that this goose was a disappointment. We strive to offer products that will, at minimum, satisfy all customers. We realize that the description should have been better to properly inform discerning customers of how the goose would ship. We cherish the holidays and the meals within them.
We will reach out to you via email to offer you a solution to this issue.
We are very sorry for your disappointment.

Meats

Outstanding products for all your needs in meats and their tshirts are cool too!

Cheers,
Battle Class Society, LLC

Meats

Great selection of quality meats!

High hopes, but this goose did not fly....

Ditto to everything Nadine F said--I was stunned to have bone shards and stubs sticking out where the wings should have been present. And no goose fat, no liver, no heart....all trimmed away and gone. Seriously? At these prices? Unfortunately, I also did not have a good experience with my meal--the goose was extremely tough and dry. And the gravy was a sad disappointment without the necessary ingredients...may have partially been my fault, but I had misgivings about this bird from the moment I saw the condition, and they were born out. Maybe it was just too small. Larger size options should be available.

I do, however, APPLAUD the delivery system. It arrived on time, and partially thawed, just as promised. At least I had something to put on the table!

Thanks for trying, but not sure this will ever be a repeat at this rate.....and I, too, was really hoping you would be my new go-to goose provider!

Hello Pamela,
We are very sorry for the lackluster performance of this goose for your Christmas meal. We take the holidays seriously and for one of our products to not pull through is a huge disappointment for us. If we offer this goose again, we will make sure to update the description so customers know what to expect.
We will reach out to you to offer you a solution to this goose issue. We want everyone to be, at minimum, satisfied with the purchase.
Thank you for reaching out.

High expectations and sad disappointment !

As a 78 year old, living alone, and unable to celebrate Christmas with my family and friends, I decided to make the same meal I make for all who gathered at my home each Christmas for the last 45 years. Caution led me to use the internet for all my purchases-food or essentials. Every year I served two or three roasted geese. I was so happy when I found you website and the offer of an 8 pound goose. I had decided to make a Christmas dinner for myself, just to keep the tradition. You understand that I have had many years of experience preparing geese. After defrosting your goose and opening the package I was astounded to find a goose with only 1/2 a segment of the wing joint nearest the body, The other wing had only the joint nearest the body, and the end the joint was crudely cut. Every goose I have ever purchased had all three joins of the wing. These are necessary to create the goose stock that will make the gravy . I was aghast to find no interior fat on the bird. It had all been removed. Rendering this fat was part of the reward of roasting a goose. This fat, is delicious, and healthier than butter or oil for sautéing. I was deprived of this, Also the flaps over the opening where removed, another source of fat and skin to be added to the stock pot. The neck skin was also missing. There was only a portion of neck sent and no liver. Perhaps this is acceptable to your customers, I, however found it a great disappointment. I thought I had found a new resource that would reward me with other wonderful choices. After this disappointing experience, both with the sloppy condition of the goose and the missing parts that have prevented me from continuing my Christmas tradition, I would be hard put to order from you again. This is truly sad because in this day of dangerous exposure outside the home, I could have made use of all you have to offer. As a last thought, the goose was delicious, however the gravy was a poor second to what I enjoyed in the past.
Thank you for the opportunity to express these thoughts.
Sincerely,
Nadine Fuchs

Hi Nadine. I am very sorry for your disappointment. Christmas dinner is special and we are also disappointed that you are not happy. We should have done a better job at describing the goose so you could have imagined it prior to receiving it.
We will reach out to you via email to offer you a solution to your lackluster Goose dinner.
Thank you for trying us and our sincere apologies for not delivering what you wanted to receive.

Gift box thank you!!

Awesome!! This gift box is awesome! My family has really enjoyed it. Thank you very much!

happy seasonings

a great blend of spices. it really enhances the flavor of the meat. I've also tried it on eggs ! and it's great.

D
Gift-Card
D.H.C.C.
Excellent,Excellent!!!!!

The Best!!! Rib Eye,Chicken excellent service, excellent product!!! 5 stars!!!! Thanks Scott,Nolan. Happy Trails

Bad Cuts of Meat Included

One of the cuts of meat that was included in this box was not identifiable. When I tried cooking it, I couldn't cut through the tough sinew and fat that was covering the piece of meat. I'm not sure if a bad cut was accidentally thrown in or if another issue occurred. This is the first time (out of many times ordering from this company) that I have experienced this issue.

Hi Katelyn. Oh my, we are so sorry! I am wondering if it was the Bison Flat Iron. While we provide certain cut specifications to the butchers we work with, each animal is unique. It is definitely not normal or intentional that this product would be vacuum packaged. Regardless, we will make this right for you. We will follow up with an email.
Again, our sincere apologies Katelyn!