Stay Classy Meats Product Reviews

Read what our customers have to say about our product and service. We aim to provide a great product with great service.
Based on 955 reviews
Katharine Janiesch
5 star

Easy purchase online! Made an excellent gift, live the products!

Excellent Quality Beet

Very much enjoyed these Wagyu Beef Patties! Excellent quality and flavor!!!

Montana Ranch Hat

Big shout out to stay classy for the hat, super comfy and the color just gets better with age! It’s definitely my go to cap anywhere I go! Thanks guys.

All around awesome

The product was fabulous and delicious . The delivery was perfect and the updates on our order were so helpful ! I will be ordering more and giving as gifts ! Thank you !

Montana Sampler Box
ryan baker
Great value and wonderful variety

Loved the wagyu burgers and the brauts, both fried well in the air fryer!

decent, but not the quality they claim to be

These are pretty good, but not even close to as good as the regular ground wagyu I have gotten from Stay Classy in the past. They are not any better than regular burgers.

Delicious, fast, and frozen

My order came fast, was frozen, and is delicious. Thank you so much!

Core II Box
Adrienne Ellis
Great quality

I've ordered the Core II Box a few times now. Same as my previous experiences, the meat is always great quality! It's an excellent way to try new cuts and flavors too. From my last order, we were pleasantly surprised to really appreciate the Boneless Berkshire Pork Schnitzel. Also, never would have thought to try the Coffee Chile Dry Rub but WOW. Very happy that was included in the box so we can try on future meals. We love SCM!


I can't say enough good things about Stay Classy and the meat box we get each month. I just got done cooking the GF T-Bones last night for myself and the kids and they came out excellent. Stay Classy always provides an amazing product.

Keep up the great work!


The jerky was SO tastey! We packed this for a camping trip and it was the perfect snack for us (2 adults)! We'll definitely be ordering again.


Best chicken I've ever tasted

Premium II Box
Ken Elflein
High quality and continuous variety

I’ve been getting this box for over a year. The variety in the box rotates every few months, so I never get burnt out of cooking the same things. The quality of the meat is incredible! I’ll never go back to store bought chicken, because now I notice how much it shrinks while cooking compared to Stay Classy’s chicken. The ground beef quality is noticeably different as well. The monthly addition bison to my family’s diet makes eating healthier a little easier.

Also love the last minute substitutions and appreciate the hand checked itemized invoice in each box! I won’t be going anywhere else to buy my meat.


Very tender and tasty

Wasn't very impressed

I was excited to receive our 1/16 of a cow. But, I wasn't very impressed with what we received. Many of the packages weren't sealed properly and there was blood all over inside the box. Thank goodness I have a FoodSaver, so I could re-do the packaging before storing my meat. I was also disappointed that the Top Round Roast, was only 1/2" thick, so it was more of a steak than a roast. The marrow bones were great and the (one) sirloin tip steak we received was great. But, I would never order this item again. I'm usually very happy with the subscription boxes I receive.

Blade steak

Don’t waste your time or money with this cut of meat. I marinated it for 5 hours cooked it on the grill to medium rare. This Blade steak was so tough and flavorless I threw it out.

Great Quality Meat

I love the meats from Stay Classy. The quality is always good.

Core II Box
Frances Murphy
Core 1 box

Excellent variety of meats. Like the fact that all the beef is pasture raised and chicken is cage free. Quality of meat is excellent


Unfortunately, there was pork in it (which I'm not supposed to have), but it was still amazing tasting! 😉
I give it a 5 out of 5!!!!!!

Just do it

Great meat and great service. I live on the east coast and everything arrives in a timely manner and very frozen.

Love the taste of the Jerky

The jerky mixed with the Huckleberry Vodka is great! A nice touch of spice with the pepper. What I like is that the jerky is not totally dried out like some. It has some flexibility and easy to chew and absorb the flavors.

Halibut 8oz-Awesome!

Excellent product and lightning fast shipment. Great taste and will order again.

terrible customer service

Have tried to cancel my subscription for two months. Just got another package fully defrosted with blood in the bottom of the box.

Hi Jonathan. You originally cancelled your order after it had shipped. We could not cancel an order that was already in transit.
However, for this past month, we failed to cancel your subscription. I have gone in and confirmed that your order was cancelled. What concerns me more than the cancellation is “another” bloody box. Why did you not let us know on the first one you received. We back our product and shipment 100%. I have also refunded you the amount paid due to your original confirmation of cancellation and the bloody box. This is definitely not how we intend that customers receive their order.
It is always a bummer to receive a 1 star review. We are very fair people and we do take care of our customers. We obviously made a mistake on cancelling your order but a simple message to us would have garnered the same response as your 1 star message. I hope in the future you look at small businesses differently and communicate with them a bit more before trying to make it difficult for them to operate.

We appreciate the business you have given us and we will be here in the future.

Wishing you the best,


Bison - Eighth of Bison
Heather Hobbins

The bison brats are a favorite! The flavors are very tastey and did not disappoint.
The bison jerky was hard to chew.
I was really disappointed with the bone-in ribeye. It had orange tissue that was hard to chew. It reminded me a lot of the jerky.
The ground bison is great! I used a StayClassy Chili recipe and it turned out really good!

Wagyu + Pork Burger

I made the burgers on the grill. They were delicious and I definitely would buy again!

Whole Goose ~8-10 lbs
Kurban Niyaz
The best goose

It's my second time ordering goose from the same seller as I'm happy with my earlier order. We often prepare a whole goose kebab for our guests with our own recipe. Everybody loved that dish, and it was the only dish that has completely gone during the party. The negative thing is it's very difficult to locate goose online those days.